2014-No Game (Olympics)
2013-No Game (lockout)
2012-Marian Gaborik, N.Y. Rangers
2011-Patrick Sharp, Chicago
2010-No Game (Olympics)
2009-Alex Kovalev, Montreal
2008-Eric Staal, Carolina
2007-Daniel Briere, Buffalo
2006-No Game (Olympics)
2005-No Game (lockout)
2004-Joe Sakic, Colorado
2003-Dany Heatley, Atlanta
2002-Eric Daze (North America), Chicago
2001-Bill Guerin (North America), Boston
2000-Pavel Bure (World), Florida
1999-Wayne Gretzky (North America), N.Y. Rangers
1998-Teemu Selanne (World), Anaheim
1997-Mark Recchi, Montreal
1996-Ray Bourque, Boston
1995-No Game (lockout)
1994-Mike Richter, N.Y. Rangers
1993-Mike Gartner, N.Y. Rangers
1992-Brett Hull, St. Louis
1991-Vincent Damphousse, Toronto
1990-Mario Lemieux, Pittsburgh
1989-Wayne Gretzky, Los Angeles
1988-Mario Lemieux, Pittsburgh
1987-No Game
1986-Grant Fuhr, Edmonton
1985-Mario Lemieux, Pittsburgh
1984-Don Maloney, N.Y. Rangers
1983-Wayne Gretzky, Edmonton
1982-Mike Bossy, N.Y. Islanders
1981-Mike Liut, St. Louis
1980-Reggie Leach, Philadelphia
1979-No Game
1978-Billy Smith, N.Y. Islanders
1977-Rick Martin, Buffalo
1976-Peter Mahovlich, Montreal
1975-Syl Apps Jr., Pittsburgh
1974-Garry Unger, St. Louis
1973-Greg Polis, Pittsburgh
1972-Bobby Orr, Boston
1971-Bobby Hull, Chicago
1970-Bobby Hull, Chicago
1969-Frank Mahovlich, Detroit
1968-Bruce Gamble, Toronto
1967-Henri Richard, Montreal
1966-No Game
1965-Gordie Howe, Detroit
1964-Jean Beliveau, Montreal
1963-Frank Mahovlich, Toronto
1962-Eddie Shack, Toronto
---
NOTE-There was no game in 1966 since the game was moved from the start of the season to midseason, and there was no game in 1979 because the Challenge Cup series between the Soviet Union and Team NHL was held instead. There was no game in 1987 because Rendez-Vous 87, a two-game series between Team NHL and the Soviet Union, replaced the All-Star Game. There was no game in 1995 or 2005 due to the owners' lockout. There was no game in 2006 and 2010 because of the NHL players' participation in the Winter Olympics.