2013 -- Mariano Rivera, New York, AL
2012 -- Melky Cabrera, San Francisco, NL
2011 -- Prince Fielder, Milwaukee, NL
2010 -- Brian McCann, Atlanta, NL
2009 -- Carl Crawford, Tampa Bay, AL
2008 -- J.D. Drew, Boston, AL
2007 -- Ichiro Suzuki, Seattle, AL
2006 -- Michael Young, Texas, AL
2005 -- Miguel Tejada, Baltimore, AL
2004 -- Alfonso Soriano, Texas, AL
2003 -- Garret Anderson, Anaheim, AL
2002 -- None
2001 -- Cal Ripken Jr., Baltimore, AL
2000 -- Derek Jeter, New York, AL
1999 -- Pedro Martinez, Boston, AL
1998 -- Roberto Alomar, Baltimore, AL
1997 -- Sandy Alomar Jr., Cleveland, AL
1996 -- Mike Piazza, Los Angeles, NL
1995 -- Jeff Conine, Florida, NL
1994 -- Fred McGriff, Atlanta, NL
1993 -- Kirby Puckett, Minnesota, AL
1992 -- Ken Griffey Jr., Seattle, AL
1991 -- Cal Ripken Jr., Baltimore, AL
1990 -- Julio Franco, Texas, AL
1989 -- Bo Jackson, Kansas City, AL
1988 -- Terry Steinbach, Oakland, AL
1987 -- Tim Raines, Montreal, NL
1986 -- Roger Clemens, Boston, AL
1985 -- LaMarr Hoyt, San Diego, NL
1984 -- Gary Carter, Montreal, NL
1983 -- Fred Lynn, California, AL
1982 -- Dave Concepcion, Cincinnati, NL
1981 -- Gary Carter, Montreal, NL
1980 -- Ken Griffey Sr., Cincinnati, NL
1979 -- Dave Parker, Pittsburgh, NL
1978 -- Steve Garvey, Los Angeles, NL
1977 -- Don Sutton, Los Angeles, NL
1976 -- George Foster, Cincinnati, NL
1975 -- Bill Madlock, Chicago, NL, and Jon Matlack, New York, NL
1974 -- Steve Garvey, Los Angeles, NL
1973 -- Bobby Bonds, San Francisco, NL
1972 -- Joe Morgan, Cincinnati, NL
1971 -- Frank Robinson, Baltimore, AL
1970 -- Carl Yastrzemski, Boston, AL
1969 -- Willie McCovey, San Francisco, NL
1968 -- Willie Mays, San Francisco, NL
1967 -- Tony Perez, Cincinnati, NL
1966 -- Brooks Robinson, Baltimore, AL
1965 -- Juan Marichal, San Francisco, NL
1964 -- John Callison, Philadelphia, NL
1963 -- Willie Mays, San Francisco, NL
1962 -- x-Maury Wills, Los Angeles, NL
1962 -- x-Leon Wagner, Los Angeles, AL
x-two games